This is a roundup of thoughts…basecamp of sorts. So far, my thinking has seen the freedom we have as being more like the whitespace that our stories leaves behind. It’s where the things, rules, codes, wants and so on do not have an impact. It’s almost like freedom isn’t a thing we have and use, but it is something we can see outlined by the things we consider to affect it or infringe upon it. Like moving an item from a dusty shelf…where we see the almost shocking reminder that things could be so different. I wonder if this is partly why whenever I see a blank piece of paper, I crave to draw or scribble on it? Hmmm…or why people feel that need to graffiti (some graffiti I’ve seen, by the way, is truly beautiful…so I’m not suggesting anything wasteful or destructive here)? Maybe it’s more like using that freedom that is suddenly exposed and on show? Or I could just be a natural born doodler. Or maybe freedom can be a little scary and unfamiliar…
In essence, if I assume that freedom is the ability to do what we want (within the bounds of feasibility–we can’t breathe unaided underwater, for example) whenever we want, then each and every one of us is free. But what chaos that would be!? Animals have their social groupings and behaviours that remove this chaos so the group survives and thrives. They assign roles and ‘punish’ their members for inappropriate behaviour.
We’re taught about restraint from a very young age, reinforced by tradition, expectation, promises and threats, rewards and punishments and so on. I’ve always seemingly had a quite compliant viewpoint on things. I think I’ve seen the sense in doing things a set way from an early age, and that means that (yes…I know…goody-goody-two-shoes) I do not tend to resist. But I see the sense in this compliance; it makes things generally easier, safer, smoother and better for everyone. It’s something that’s instilled in us with calls to get up and dressed, breakfasted and teeth brushed and so on from before we go to nursery. A general consensus on how things should and must go so that everyone can get out the door to do what has to be done.
This governance and learning to self govern doesn’t sound like the infringement or suppression or stifling of freedom, but more a way to choose more carefully so that we can get stuff done in a way that is beneficial to all, either from an effort, time or cost point of view. The freedom of a two-year-old to whip all their clothes off while Mum is trying to get the shoes on her five-year-old is great if you believe freedom is something we should all be able to explore and revel in, but not so great when school starts at 8.50am and you now have a giggling infant running around butt naked.
What interests me here is how these learnt restrictions, such as the ‘locked door to an unlocked room’, and that reinforced idea of ‘not being able to’ extends to all closed doors. There are around me many gardens with no fences and paths running through open woodlands, yet I always walk on the pavement or stick to the path. Closed doors are locked doors unless stated otherwise…and I always knock. This is good manners and no bad thing, but on a wider scale…how many places do I avoid or not enter simply because I think I can’t? This acceptance does seem like writing on a page highlighting the edges of where I could’ve gone if the words weren’t there. The extent of my freedom ending where whitespace meets justified text.
Then later, when we wear what someone else says we must wear…those itchy tights (that must have been designed to always ruckle up round the ankles) and skirts, for example. Old conventions that we follow…maybe, just because! Winters were miserable in skirts, and I was so very glad when the school said my daughters could wear trousers. It was a comfort. It might sound silly, but again on a wider scale, tradition is dictating the empty spaces left to us. Not just tradition, but religion, our hindbrains, what our parents taught us, and many other sources of pressure.
These two ideas are different in as much as one is family, and although it must be a common thing in every household, it’s still a very personal form of getting a consensus by tailoring thinking from everything that’s possible to what is actually in this house at this moment possible, and often that is dictated by the expectations and demands upon the individuals within it. There is a potential fluidity in the curtailing or manicuring of freedom as week becomes weekends and holidays versus working days. And if anyone knows how to get a two-year-old to stand still and remain dressed in the mornings, that would be one of those pivotal steps forward for mankind.
The second idea, perhaps obviously, and I apologise for the naivety of these ramblings, deals with freedoms as we apply the idea to our neighbours and other households and in work environments. And often we cut freedom’s cloth to the length of maintaining others’ right to privacy. We are taught to respect. That closed door or ‘not there’ wall becomes sacrosanct. However, beneath all that, there is and always will be the freedom to open any door and walk across any garden or wander off any path. I have often been amused and irritated by my parents allowing other kids to do something that they forbade me to do. And I think most people on the planet, when they plead the case of their friend being allowed to do something, have had an argument presented to them along the lines of: Oh, and if your friend jumped off a cliff, would you do it too?!
It’s an interesting point. What you can do in one household, you can’t do in another. Is that another dust-free spot that’s so blatant and shocking we find when we start moving ornaments around? Does it imply one person’s freedoms being impinged, stolen away? Oh, I dust quite regularly, by the way…although there are a few times when I’m poorly, where you could write some decent haikus in the dust, and I must admit, I really do question then how housework impinges terribly on my freedom!
But that thought still prods, that underneath all this, we are free to open doors and walk where we like…but at that point, we have conscience and consequences. Be back to this later….gotta dust! Hehehehe
Leave a Reply